SHARE

Energy Analysis: So Much to Know...

Posted by Shawna Henderson on December 16, 2014
Energy Analysis: So Much to Know... The passive solar sunspace addition on a 150-year-old Acadian house supplies nearly 70% of the annual heating load (the house also underwent a deep energy retrofit).

It's hard to wrap your head around the amount of number crunching that goes into energy analysis, and how to prioritize your time and effort when working on a project. There are energy modelling tools that can be used that make it easier, but in a lot of cases, the easier the modelling tool is to use, and the less actual, real-world performance testing data you input, the more likely the result will be a ball-park figure that doesn't relate to actual energy usage, or actual heating or cooling loads.

Here's a good example from Jeremy Begby's November 17, 2014 blog post at IE3. He ran a comparison in WrightSoft (one of the industry's standard software for heat loss/heat gain calculations) using a real-world example. In the first run, they used the default 'loose' air leakage rate, and in the second run, they used the actual blower door test results (single point method). The results were dramatically different:

  • The heating load using the blower door results was 1.4 times higher than when the software's generic 'loose' envelope rating was applied.
  • The cooling load was another 3/4 ton higher using the blower door test results.
  • While infiltration accounted for 36% of the total heating and cooling load using the 'loose' envelope rating native to the software, the blower door test results indicated that infiltration made up a whopping 64% of the total load.

The estimate not only undersizes the equipment significantly, but also understates the importance of improving the building envelope when upgrading the HVAC systems in a house. Using real-world data points like blower door tests becomes much more important as you start to approach low/zero energy space conditioning and water heating targets in existing housing.

For example:

Last month, I wrote an article for Oil and Energy Magazine that looked at passive solar design, and I sketched out some of the ways that adding indirect gain in the form of an attached sunspace or closed-in porch can improve the building envelope. I don't model a sunspace addition in WrightSoft, instead, I build out the house-as-is model, ideally using the blower door test results. I typically cross-reference that with a monthly energy use model built in Hot2000 (because I'm Canadian, eh? Plus, I've been using it for over two decades, and can consistently get within ±10% of actual energy use).

Taking the as-is model, I run several scenarios for envelope improvements (first air sealing reductions, then additional insulation, then window replacements).

Then I model the proposed sunspace design using an excel sheet that I built out a billion years ago based on manual heat loss/heat gain protocols. I have it set up so it gives me monthly gain/loss totals for the sunspace, so I can see what I need to do to reduce monthly losses and when I need to incorporate shading or increase overhang sizes. I also calculate the heat loss 'credit' the house achieves with the buffering effect associated with the reduced area of wall/foundation area that is exposed to the elements and seasonal temperature extremes. Here's part of what that analysis looks like, this one with a wormy bit of ductwork in the top of an attached greenhouse for heat (but not air) transfer between the food- (and moisture-) producing greenhouse and the living space (click on the image for a full, larger PDF):

In addition, I do seasonal shading modelling when there is southwest and/or west-facing glass to make sure that there will be no sneaky overheating in the summer months I especially like this suite of tools for solar design modelling from Sustainable By Design, out of Washington state.

The only thing missing in my analysis is real-world monitoring. I follow up to find out what energy bills are when I can, and there is a good correlation between the model and the actual use, where the work was completed as specified (that's another topic for discussion...). In an ideal world, clients would jump at paying for the privilege to be monitored. But, mainly, they just pay me for consulting.

 

This post originally appeared on the Blue House Energy blog, 18 November 2014.

 

Comments
Add a new blog comment!

Enter your comments in the box below:

(Please note that all blog entries and comments are subject to review prior to posting.)

 

While we will do our best to monitor all comments and blog posts for accuracy and relevancy, Home Energy is not responsible for content posted by our readers or third parties. Home Energy reserves the right to edit or remove comments or blog posts that do not meet our community guidelines.

Recent Blogs
Energy Analysis: So Much to Know...

Energy Analysis: So Much to Know...

Shawna Henderson

It's hard to wrap your head around the amount of number crunching that goes into energy analysis, and how to prioritize your time and effort when working on a project. There are energy modelling tools that can be used that make it easier, but in a lot of cases, the easier the modelling tool is to use, and the less actual, real-world performance testing data you input, the more likely the result will be a ... [continue reading]

The Wired Home: Which Technologies Actually Work?

The Wired Home: Which Technologies Actually Work?

Abby Perkins

With today's sky-high energy costs, homeowners and energy industry professionals alike are constantly looking for ways to increase energy efficiency and save money. Fortunately, advancements in home automation technology have made this easier than ever. [continue reading]

A Green Way to Insulate for Extreme Energy Efficiency

A Green Way to Insulate for Extreme Energy Efficiency

Rob Nicely

Back in the '70s, California’s Title 24 revised the state’s building code to include limits for energy usage in built environments. The go-to solution for stemming the amount of energy required for heating and cooling quickly became insulation. For decades, the most frequently used type of insulation was fiberglass batt, laid between framing in walls and ceilings. To work effectively, insulation has to completely stop the movement of air. The fiberglass ... [continue reading]

The Energy Industry is Up for Grabs

The Energy Industry is Up for Grabs

Martha Wampler Behm

Almost 30% of Americans would leave their utility if they could, according to Shelton Group’s 10th annual Energy Pulse study. And of those, fully 64% would choose a non-utility alternative like SolarCity, Google, or Comcast. [continue reading]

Energy, Inc. and LockState to Provide Advanced Control for Energy Monitoring

Energy, Inc. and LockState to Provide Advanced Control for Energy Monitoring

John Cargile

Energy Inc., a privately held corporation that designs and manufactures real-time electricity management systems for residential and commercial use, recently announced the integration with home automation and load control device manufacturer, LockState. By broadening the flexibility of interoperable devices within the home area network, LockState, maker of door locks, plug strips, thermostats and cameras, can help electric utilities offer consumers more ways to save energy, and to participate in demand response programs, particularly during peak ... [continue reading]

Complete HVAC with Whole Home Performance

Complete HVAC with Whole Home Performance

Sophia Moore

Every contractor needs to know how important efficiency is for this industry, as the world grows around us we have new technology every day. Being able to offer and explain the latest, most efficient equipment can give you a great edge on your market. Although in some situations, having the most efficient equipment simply doesn’t cut it and there are many different issues that can prevent your install from performing as advertised, including: [continue reading]

A Pause for Reflection: After 30 Years, Conservation Services Group Considers the Future of Energy Efficiency

A Pause for Reflection: After 30 Years, Conservation Services Group Considers the Future of Energy Efficiency

Kevin Farrell

In early September, Conservation Services Group (CSG) celebrated its 30-year anniversary with more than 200 guests. During the celebration at the company’s headquarters in Westborough, Mass., founder and CEO, Steve Cowell spoke about the historic successes and challenges faced by the energy community, using the anniversary as an opportunity to reflect on the growth of residential energy efficiency and look toward the future. [continue reading]

Congratulations to the Home Performance with Energy Star Housing Innovation Award Winners!

Congratulations to the Home Performance with Energy Star Housing Innovation Award Winners!

Ely Jacobsohn

Winners for the Department of Energy’s 2014 Housing Innovations Award were announced on September 23rd during a special event at Energy & Environmental Building Alliance (EBBA)’s Excellence in Building Conference in St. Louis, MO. The Housing Innovation Awards support the Department’s commitment to help harness American ingenuity to commercialize and deploy cutting-edge technologies, as well as to promote improving the energy efficiency of the U.S. housing stock. Home Performance ... [continue reading]

Hot Water at any Faucet in 3 to 5 Seconds

Hot Water at any Faucet in 3 to 5 Seconds

Rob Nicely

Studies show that the average home wastes more than 3,650 gallons a year waiting for the hot water to make it to the faucet. And, according to the EPA, about 15% of the energy used in conventional hot water delivery systems is wasted. That’s an unnecessary burden on your client's energy budget as well as on our area’s limited water supply and other natural resources. [continue reading]

How to Make Sure Your Kids Grow Up to Be Energy-Conscious Adults

How to Make Sure Your Kids Grow Up to Be Energy-Conscious Adults

Kurt Jacobson

Do you know that, according to the DOE, the United States uses up energy worth nearly a million dollars every minute? We have gotten so used to having energy available at the flick of a finger that we find it difficult to believe that most of its sources are fast-depleting. [continue reading]

Earn BPI CEU credits
HEP
Home Performance with EnergyStar
Email Newsletter

Home Energy E-Newsletter

Sign up for our free monthly
E-Newsletter!

Harness the power of
HOME PERFORMANCE!

Get the Home Energy
e-newsletter

FREE!

SUBSCRIBE

NOW!