Air Flow Measurements in the Bag
Many people in the building performance field know about a certain, easy-to-perform air flow test that involves common household items. If you are not among them, read on. If you already know about the garbage bag air flow test read on anyway—you might learn something new about it.
To perform the test, take a garbage bag, a wire coat hanger that you don’t hang clothes on, some adhesive tape, and a watch. Bend the coat hanger into a circle, square, or rectangle big enough to fit completely around the register where you want to measure air flow. Fit the opening of the garbage bag around the coat hanger and tape it in place (you don’t have to make it tight, just so it stays on the hanger).Now you have the necessary technology.The biggest challenge for those who are technologically inept is how to avoid poking a hole in the garbage bag with the coat hanger.The authors welcome any tips regarding this point.
Put the completely deflated garbage bag rig that you’ve created over a supply register.Time how long it takes for the bag to fully inflate.Or put the fully inflated garbage bag rig over a return register and time how long it takes for the bag to deflate.While in theory you could simply divide the volume of the bag by the time it takes to inflate or deflate, most practitioners choose to use a calibration table to determine air flow (see Table 1).
The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) began publicizing the garbage bag air flow test in the early ’90s and has used it in several field tests (usually when contractors objected to using CMHC’s cumbersome duct test rig). In its literature, CMHC specifies using a Glad 66 cm x 91 cm garbage bag.When your bag is laid out flat, it should approximate that bag’s dimensions: 26 inches by 36 inches (about 2 ft x 3 ft). Easy enough to measure, or even approximate.
The garbage bag air flow test is very appropriate for estimating forced-air furnace flows and for help in balancing HVAC systems (see “Garbage Bag Educator”). It can also be useful when installing or checking flows from exhaust devices such as bathroom or kitchen fans. Sometimes you can raise a full bag to the exhaust grille and time its deflation. Often, it is easier to go to the outlet hood and time the bag’s inflation. We recommended this method to homeowners who want to do a rough check on heat recovery ventilator (HRV) balance.
One of the first uses of the garbage bag test was for someone in Canada who was getting no heat on the second floor in his relatively new suburban house. Several tradespeople had tried to solve the problem with no success.The man’s furnace was oversized, as is true in most new housing, so there should have been no shortage of heat. The garbage bag test showed that only 2 of his 18 supply ducts had flows greater than 10 CFM. His duct system was essentially blocked, probably by the air conditioning coil, since the only two registers with decent flow took off before the AC coil.
The beauty of the garbage bag test is its availability. Even if you forget to bring any equipment or the calibration table, you can still build a test rig and use it to measure air flow in almost any house within ten minutes.“Excuse me, have you got a garbage bag and a wire coat hanger and some tape?” The visual nature of the test is easy for homeowners to interpret.A 2-second inflation (75 CFM) is a healthy, robust flow.An inflation of less than 10 CFM (roughly 15 seconds) is almost comically slow. The relative performance of several supply registers is obvious even without a watch.
We would like to see the bag test frequently used by anyone who installs air-moving devices. It’s not designed to replace standardized HRV balancing procedures or house testing with devices such as the Duct Blaster.However, it provides a quick and effective check after the installation of forced-air ducting.You can get a good idea of the performance of all of the ducts in a house, usually within ten minutes. It is also a quick way to do a commissioning when exhaust fans are installed in houses. It is convenient, convincing, and costs next to nothing.And it’s supported by both the garbage bag and the wire hanger industries.
- FIRST PAGE
- PREVIOUS PAGE
Enter your comments in the box below:
(Please note that all comments are subject to review prior to posting.)