Strictly-Shell Man Converts
Whole-house contracting holds no mysteries for Richard Kornbluth, president and cofounder, with Frank LaSala, of EnTherm, Incorporated, in Syracuse, New York.The first time he got his hands on a blower door was in 1982.To say it was a life-changing event would be a slight exaggeration—a creeping conversion would be more accurate. It took almost a decade for him to fully incorporate blower door testing into his insulation and air sealing business. By 1992 the conversion was complete, and Kornbluth was training other contractors to use a blower door to document air leakage reductions. Performance testing has been a mainstay of his business ever since. So in early 2001, when the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) and EPA were getting ready to roll out a program to improve the efficiency of existing housing in New York State and were looking for contracting businesses to enroll in the program,Kornbluth’s EnTherm was an obvious fit.Obvious as it was, the involvement has dramatically altered Kornbluth’s business.“Since 2001, our volume of business has grown by 50%,” says Kornbluth.
Home Performance with Energy Star,EPA’s energy efficiency program tailored for existing housing, has now debuted in five states (see “Home Performance Expands Across Country”). Although the program takes shape differently in each area, its basic approach and goals are consistent across the country.Home Performance with Energy Star emphasizes training contractors to offer whole-house assessments of a home’s comfort and energy problems, as well as the solutions to those problems.Kornbluth was contacted by Conservation Services Group, the implementer of the New York program, because his company had a track record in performancetesting their work.“I owned two blower doors and an infrared scanner,” says Kornbluth.“But we did strictly shell work.”
Becoming a Home Performance with Energy Star contractor in New York State requires getting certified by the Building Performance Institute (BPI).Kornbluth is currently certified by BPI as a Building Analyst I Specialist, a Shell Specialist, and a Mobile Homes Specialist. Besides himself, EnTherm has seven BPI Building Analyst I Specialists on staff. Of these seven, three are also BPI Shell Specialists and two of the three Shell Specialists are also BPI Heating Specialists.The shell training, which Kornbluth conducts for his staff, covers the concept of the house as a system; the transport of heat, air, and moisture in buildings; driving forces; combustion basics; building construction; insulation, ventilation, and thermal bypasses; health and safety testing procedures, including draft,worstcase depressurization, and CO testing protocols; blower door testing; and duct leakage testing.
Today,Kornbluth’s business model has changed from strictly shell work to offering customers whole-house solutions to their home performance problems (see “One Good Turn”).Now, when a customer calls EnTherm with a specific complaint, such as “I need more insulation in my walls” or “I want to replace my windows,” the response is that the company will send out a building performance estimator to look at the whole house.“All my estimators make a strong effort to talk about houses as a system,” says Kornbluth.“They try to get the customer to understand that if you insulate a house, you can change how that house works.” If a customer is sufficiently interested, EnTherm will return and conduct a full energy audit for a $150 fee. EnTherm will credit that fee back to the customer, should he or she sign up for any work. Finally, so as not to leave a worried customer behind, the estimator tackles the financial fear factor by outlining the financing that exists to pay for home performance work.
To utility customers in New York State, Home Performance with Energy Star offers, through NYSERDA, three financing incentives. Low-interest loans—currently at 5.99%—are available to cover the cost of the contracting work. People who qualify on the basis of income can get a 50% incentive—up to $5,000—to pay for home performance work. Finally, those who can afford to pay for improvements, and choose not to use the financing, are eligible for a cash incentive equal to 10% of the project’s cost.
Kornbluth attributes his 50% increase in business primarily to the availability of these financing programs.The competitive financing packages are attractive to new customers not only because they lower the cost of getting the
work done, but also because they simplify the process. In one visit, Kornbluth’s estimators can identify solutions to a customer’s comfort and energy problems and help a customer to figure out how to pay for the necessary work. From Kornbluth’s perspective, the financing has enabled him to sell complete—and therefore more effective—home performance packages that include insulation and air sealing, windows and doors, and HVAC improvements. Expanding their service offerings to include HVAC work has given them an additional profit center.“The average size of our jobs has increased substantially,” says Kornbluth.
To address his customers’HVAC needs in a timely manner,Kornbluth has actively striven to establish contracting relationships with several HVAC shops—a challenging task. To work with him, an HVAC contractor needs to be willing to be trained to take a house-as-a-system approach to furnace repair and replacement and to get certified by BPI.Kornbluth talked to his customers and to HVAC equipment suppliers to identify potential subcontractors. He now has good subcontracting relationships
with three small HVAC companies; he finds that the smaller, one- to three-person shops tend to be more flexible in their approach.Kornbluth’s approach to maintaining good working relationships no doubt helps.“Our policy with subcontractors is, they get a bill in on Wednesday,we get a check to them on Friday,” he says.
EnTherm’s business has also gotten a boost from the Home Performance with Energy Star program’s marketing efforts, particularly when these efforts were targeted in the Syracuse area. “The use of This Old House’s Steve Thomas as a spokesperson helped significantly,” says Kornbluth (see “Performance Comes Home for Steve Thomas,” HE Nov/Dec ’01, p. 43). EnTherm has also used NYSERDA’s brochures and videotapes as selling tools, which has been somewhat helpful.
Kornbluth’s relationship with Home Performance with Energy Star may be rosy, but he cautions that there is a downside. Successful whole-house contracting requires more management; it means coordinating different trades to perform the insulation, windows and doors, and HVAC components of a job.And then there is the dreaded p-word. “Any contractor who is interested in participating in New York’s program must be prepared for the required paperwork,” Kornbluth warns.“Pre- and postaudits have to be posted in Homecheck or TREAT software,workscopes have to be submitted for approval by NYSERDA, and completion certificates have to be signed by customers and submitted to NYSERDA.” Jobs that qualify for a NYSERDA consumer incentive require more paperwork, but this cost is balanced by a NYSERDA contractor audit incentive for every job submitted.This audit incentive is 5% of the total contracted work, up to a maximum of $10,000.
Paperwork is not the only drawback. As a BPI-certified contractor,Kornbluth cannot take on a job if the customer refuses to address health and safety concerns.“We have had customers with unvented gas fireplaces who have refused to disconnect them to have shell work done, or who have refused to install kitchen exhaust fans when their ovens made more than 50 ppm of CO,” he says.He knows that these customers will find other contractors who will limit the scope of their work to just adding insulation or just replacing windows. Still, the benefits of participating in Home Performance with Energy Star and conducting thorough whole-house retrofits far outweigh the disadvantages.“ We know that we are not leaving houses and their occupants in unsafe or unhealthy conditions. There is a clear peace-of-mind factor here,”Kornbluth says.
That peace of mind is clearly being felt by EnTherm’s customers; 40%-50% of their new business comes from customer referrals.They also use media advertising, including truck signs and some TV and radio spots. In an innovative twist,Kornbluth somewhat sheepishly admits to using very targeted telemarketing. EnTherm will call homes around existing job sites to explain to the residents the type of work that is being performed and to ask whether they have any comfort or performance complaints.
Kornbluth says his biggest challenge, with his increased work volume, is hiring qualified employees. His training skills have gotten an extended workout lately as he transforms his new hires into the kind of employees who will leave a satisfied customer in a well-performing house. Could Kornbluth ever see his company going back to the old ways of strictly blow-and-go installation jobs? No, he says, those days belong to the past—at least one conversion ago.
Enter your comments in the box below:
(Please note that all comments are subject to review prior to posting.)