One Year Later: Ten Lessons from the Grissom Lane Net Zero Senior Apartments
Designed, built, and managed by Community Housing Partners (CHP), Grissom Lane Apartments in Blacksburg, Virginia, are affordable homes for seniors and the first EarthCraft Virginia Net Zero Certified homes in the state. As such, each home produces as much energy as, or more energy than, it uses. One of the primary reasons the four duplexes were built to net zero standards was so that residents age 55 and over could continue aging in the same home for as long as possible.
In 2012, CHP and the town of Blacksburg committed to developing Grissom Lane Apartments to address a growing need for senior housing in the New River Valley. Through their combined experience, they realized that aging in place can be very difficult if a home cannot efficiently and cost effectively maintain the inhabitants’ physical comfort level. An inefficient home can often lead to utility bills that weigh heavily on the fixed incomes of many aging citizens. In fact, the Older Americans 2012 Key Indicators of Well Being report assembled by the Federal Interagency Forum on Aging Related Statistics identified housing cost burden (expenditures on housing and utilities that exceed 30% of household income) as one of the most significant housing problems facing aging Americans. While Grissom Lane resident utility bills are currently paid by CHP as the property manager, it is the hope of CHP and the town of Blacksburg that Grissom Lane will serve as a model both of innovative sustainable design and of ways in which that design can support affordable aging in place.
Once the homes were built and occupied, the units had to go through one year of energy monitoring in order to verify that they actually produced as much energy as, or more energy than, they used. During that one-year period, CHP learned ten invaluable—and surprising—lessons, according to the development’s energy monitor, Benjamin Knopp of Think Little, the company that served as energy efficiency consultant for the project.
The solar PVs outperformed all estimates.
The solar PV systems at Grissom Lane Apartments performed better than CHP’s and the installer's estimates. They proved to be extremely consistent and reliable.
The ducted mini-split heat pumps performed up to CHP’s high expectations.
Many people do not know that there is such a thing as a ducted mini-split, or that a well-designed high-efficiency heat pump may not need a backup heat source such as electric resistance. CHP was able to design a system that was 40% more efficient than a typical new 14 SEER heat pump, without electric-resistance heat, for about the same cost.
Minute-by-minute energy consumption data were educational.
CHP learned several interesting things by analyzing the minute-by-minute energy consumption data from the energy-monitoring systems. For instance, there were some unusual energy spikes at certain times of the day. CHP shared these data with the residents and identified behaviors that were based on misunderstandings of the energy systems in their homes. By filling in the gaps in tenant education, CHP was able to improve resident comfort while simultaneously reducing unnecessary energy consumption.
During 4°F temperatures, the mini-split units used as little as 30% of their heating capacity to maintain resident comfort.
The real-world performance of the mini-splits proved to be exceptional. Credit must also be given to the tight air sealing and the R-60 roof, the R-20 underslab, and the R-26 exterior wall insulation.
When occupants used Nighttime Setback, the heating system used twice as much energy as it did when occupants took the set-it-and-forget-it approach.
This discovery was made when CHP compared the energy consumption of the heating systems in two units that maintained the same average indoor temperature, but whose occupants used the thermostat differently. It seems counterintuitive, because using Nighttime Setback can save energy in homes with oversized single-speed equipment. However, CHP observed that using Nighttime Setback increases energy usage in high-performance homes with variable-speed equipment. CHP’s real-world evidence of just how much energy can be saved by leaving the thermostat at a comfortable temperature can benefit owners of high-performance homes.
Increasing the water heater tank set point reduced energy use.
This is another counterintuitive finding based on real-world energy usage data. Residents were experiencing cooler showers in the winter from a combination of colder incoming water and the type of antiscald safety device built into the shower hardware. The residents began switching off the Hybrid mode on the water heaters to have hotter showers, not realizing that they were using 4 times as much energy to heat their water. CHP proposed raising the temperature set point on the water heaters but leaving them in Hybrid mode. This win-win solution allowed the residents to have the hot showers they wanted while using as little energy as possible. Ultimately, it is better to use a little more energy from a heat pump than to switch to electric-resistance heat.
Raising the thermostat temperature for the entire home used less energy than using a space heater to raise the temperature of one room.
This lesson applies to several residents who were using electric-resistance space heaters. In all cases, the residents did not realize just how much energy their space heaters were using. A couple of them purchased the space heaters in the belief that the small space heater would use less energy than their “big heating system.” In reality, their heating system could provide 3 to 4 times as much heat for the same amount of energy as the space heater. It was more efficient for them to raise the thermostat a few degrees for the entire house than for them to use a space heater to stay comfortable.
Grissom Lane Apartments would not have been Net Zero Certified without energy monitoring.
The energy monitoring allowed CHP to identify opportunities for resident education that had a big impact on total energy consumption. For instance, one unit was using over twice as much energy as the next-highest energy user. The team was able to identify the cause and provide education so that the resident could stay comfortable using only half as much energy as before.
The residents took pride in using less energy to meet the net zero goal.
The residents were generally eager to reduce their energy use to help reach the goal of EarthCraft Virginia Net Zero Certified, even though it had no financial impact on them, since their utilities were paid for by CHP. Some tenants even approached CHP to ask what they could do to reduce their energy use. After some discussion, they voluntarily replaced the incandescent lights in their plug-in lamps with LED bulbs.
The biggest variable in energy consumption was resident behavior.
At the end of the year, the resident with the highest annual energy consumption used 3 times as much energy as the resident with the lowest energy consumption.
In summary, the Grissom Lane Apartments teach us that while it is important for the home energy industry to continue to strive for increasingly efficient equipment, designs, and strategies, residents are the final active component of any energy-efficient home.
Enter your comments in the box below:
(Please note that all comments are subject to review prior to posting.)
While we will do our best to monitor all comments and blog posts for accuracy and relevancy, Home Energy is not responsible for content posted by our readers or third parties. Home Energy reserves the right to edit or remove comments or blog posts that do not meet our community guidelines.